The J. Walter Chase Trophy
(incorporated 1975)
To the winner goes the trophy
By Richard Doyle, NHS ‘59 / The Clipper Connection
January 27. 2011
The winner of the National Football League Super Bowl gets the Vince Lombardi Trophy. Some colleges fight for a musket or old oaken bucket with their arch rival each year.
Besides fighting for bragging rights each Thanksgiving Day, the Newburyport and Amesbury teams vie intently for the Chase Trophy. Not many know the history behind this award, which is named after one of the most loyal Newburyport fans to ever watch the game.
J. Walter Chase, along with his wife Reta, was one of the most faithful fans to follow Clipper football for many years, dating back to the 1950s. Along with his daughters Jean and Carol and their grandchildren, the family could be seen and heard cheering wildly on the Newburyport side of the field no matter where an athletic contest was held. They would drive for miles in all kinds of weather to support the Clipper teams and faithfully back the kids win or lose.
Walter Chase was an active member of the Boosters Club for decades, which promoted good sportsmanship in all Clipper teams and rewarded them with an annual banquet, regardless of their records.
He was a fixture at almost all Newburyport contests for years and years. When he died, his wife and daughters continued to attend the games and back the various athletic squads. Since there was no award given to the winning team on Thanksgiving, it was decided to establish a trophy in his name for this purpose.
The idea originally came from highly successful NHS football coach Jim Stehlin and the Boosters Club in 1975, who wanted new interest in the Thanksgiving game each year. Chase had died in 1974, so it seemed a natural fit for this award. The club paid for the trophy and the engraving each year, but now it is done by the Chase family.
The Chase Trophy is a big, beautiful, gold football mounted on a stand with a plaque that bears the name of the winning school and the year. It is housed in that school’s trophy case for one year until the next Thanksgiving.
The school that won it previously brings it to the game. In the beginning, the president of the Boosters Club made the presentation to the winning coach and captain, but now the Chase grandchildren make the award on the field after the final whistle.
A true Newburyport son
In addition to truly being a super fan, Walter Chase was a native Newburyporter, born in 1889 on the farm at Curzon Mill in the north end of Newburyport. He was one of nine children who grew up on the farm and was the last Chase descendant to leave the house, now known as Maudslay State Park Headquarters, in 1916. Walter served as an Alderman from Ward One in 1919 and as a councilor-at-large in 1920 and 1921.
For over 50 years, he was a very active member of the Baptist Church and late in life a member of the Central Congregational Church in Newburyport. In 1922, the first Boosters Club met, and Walter was a member. For several years this group didn’t meet but started up again the 1940s. Walter was an involved member until his death in 1975.
After his retirement from the retail business world in 1955, he attended all the games at NHS, as well as out of town games. He loved young people.
His loquacious and likable daughter Jean says that presentation of the Chase Trophy makes the family very proud. Her father was a man of high moral character, and his grandchildren and great grandchildren are thrilled to be part of the yearly presentation. Jean goes on to say that it was an honor to have the trophy given in memory of a quiet, unassuming man who did not play sports himself but had a lot of respect for the young people who did, regardless of age or race. He was always one who never wanted any attention for himself.
Each year that passes adds to the legacy of this prestigious award, which is highly coveted by Newburyport and Amesbury football teams every Thanksgiving Day.
Special thanks to Jean Chase for supplying much of the information used in this story.
By Richard Doyle, NHS ‘59 / The Clipper Connection
January 27. 2011
The winner of the National Football League Super Bowl gets the Vince Lombardi Trophy. Some colleges fight for a musket or old oaken bucket with their arch rival each year.
Besides fighting for bragging rights each Thanksgiving Day, the Newburyport and Amesbury teams vie intently for the Chase Trophy. Not many know the history behind this award, which is named after one of the most loyal Newburyport fans to ever watch the game.
J. Walter Chase, along with his wife Reta, was one of the most faithful fans to follow Clipper football for many years, dating back to the 1950s. Along with his daughters Jean and Carol and their grandchildren, the family could be seen and heard cheering wildly on the Newburyport side of the field no matter where an athletic contest was held. They would drive for miles in all kinds of weather to support the Clipper teams and faithfully back the kids win or lose.
Walter Chase was an active member of the Boosters Club for decades, which promoted good sportsmanship in all Clipper teams and rewarded them with an annual banquet, regardless of their records.
He was a fixture at almost all Newburyport contests for years and years. When he died, his wife and daughters continued to attend the games and back the various athletic squads. Since there was no award given to the winning team on Thanksgiving, it was decided to establish a trophy in his name for this purpose.
The idea originally came from highly successful NHS football coach Jim Stehlin and the Boosters Club in 1975, who wanted new interest in the Thanksgiving game each year. Chase had died in 1974, so it seemed a natural fit for this award. The club paid for the trophy and the engraving each year, but now it is done by the Chase family.
The Chase Trophy is a big, beautiful, gold football mounted on a stand with a plaque that bears the name of the winning school and the year. It is housed in that school’s trophy case for one year until the next Thanksgiving.
The school that won it previously brings it to the game. In the beginning, the president of the Boosters Club made the presentation to the winning coach and captain, but now the Chase grandchildren make the award on the field after the final whistle.
A true Newburyport son
In addition to truly being a super fan, Walter Chase was a native Newburyporter, born in 1889 on the farm at Curzon Mill in the north end of Newburyport. He was one of nine children who grew up on the farm and was the last Chase descendant to leave the house, now known as Maudslay State Park Headquarters, in 1916. Walter served as an Alderman from Ward One in 1919 and as a councilor-at-large in 1920 and 1921.
For over 50 years, he was a very active member of the Baptist Church and late in life a member of the Central Congregational Church in Newburyport. In 1922, the first Boosters Club met, and Walter was a member. For several years this group didn’t meet but started up again the 1940s. Walter was an involved member until his death in 1975.
After his retirement from the retail business world in 1955, he attended all the games at NHS, as well as out of town games. He loved young people.
His loquacious and likable daughter Jean says that presentation of the Chase Trophy makes the family very proud. Her father was a man of high moral character, and his grandchildren and great grandchildren are thrilled to be part of the yearly presentation. Jean goes on to say that it was an honor to have the trophy given in memory of a quiet, unassuming man who did not play sports himself but had a lot of respect for the young people who did, regardless of age or race. He was always one who never wanted any attention for himself.
Each year that passes adds to the legacy of this prestigious award, which is highly coveted by Newburyport and Amesbury football teams every Thanksgiving Day.
Special thanks to Jean Chase for supplying much of the information used in this story.
Restoration
The restoration and maintenance of the Chase Trophy takes hours of polishing, buffing and cleaning. The brass fixture on top is subject to tarnishing and pitting; while the bottom finish wears and peals. Seasonal maintenance is required to keep this trophy looking as it did to the Chase family in 1975. The 2015 restoration took approximately 6-7 hours.
The Newburyport Clippers vs. The Amesbury Indians
For the J. Walter Chase Trophy
2023: Newburyport 44, Amesbury 26 (The 100th Game)
2022: Amesbury 38, Newburyport 14
2021: Amesbury 12, Newburyport 7
2020: Season moved due to Covid-19 - No Game
2019: Newburyport 34, Amesbury 20
2018: Amesbury 8, Newburyport 0
2017: Newburyport 27, Amesbury 0
2016: Amesbury 22, Newburyport 17
2015: Newburyport 36, Amesbury 34 (OT)
2014: Newburyport 27, Amesbury 20
2013: Newburyport 21, Amesbury 7
2012: Amesbury 13, Newburyport 10
2011: Newburyport 24, Amesbury 6
2010: Newburyport 26, Amesbury 0
2009: Newburyport 33, Amesbury 0
2008: Amesbury 22, Newburyport 7
2007: Amesbury 17, Newburyport 12
2006: Amesbury 20, Newburyport 0
2005: Newburyport 20, Amesbury 0
2004: Newburyport 24, Amesbury 14
2003: Amesbury 27, Newburyport 7
2002: Newburyport 28, Amesbury 6
2001: Newburyport 46, Amesbury 16
2000: Newburyport 26, Amesbury 24
1999: Newburyport 34, Amesbury 0
1998: Newburyport 35, Amesbury 19
1997: Newburyport 42, Amesbury 6
1996: Amesbury 38, Newburyport 8
1995: Newburyport 34, Amesbury 0
1994: Newburyport 19, Amesbury 7
1993: Amesbury 14, Newburyport 0
1992: Amesbury 23, Newburyport 6
1991: Amesbury 26, Newburyport 14
1990: Newburyport 42, Amesbury 14
1989: Amesbury 35, Newburyport 6
1988: Amesbury 39, Newburyport 20
1987: Newburyport 6, Amesbury 3
1986: Amesbury 14, Newburyport 0
1985: Newburyport 20, Amesbury 14 (OT)
1984: Newburyport 25, Amesbury 14
1983: Newburyport 48, Amesbury 8
1982: Amesbury 31, Newburyport 7
1981: Newburyport 18, Amesbury 7
1980: Newburyport 26, Amesbury 6
1979: Amesbury 12, Newburyport 7
1978: Newburyport 14, Amesbury 12
1977: Newburyport 41, Amesbury 8
1976: Newburyport 35, Amesbury 0
1975: Newburyport 31, Amesbury 8 – First year that the Chase Trophy was awarded
1974: Newburyport 21, Amesbury 13
1973: Newburyport 32, Amesbury 8
1972: Newburyport 30, Amesbury 6
1971: Amesbury 16, Newburyport 0
1970: Amesbury 28, Newburyport 20
1969: Newburyport 42, Amesbury 14
1968: Newburyport 42, Amesbury 26
1967: Newburyport 34, Amesbury 0
1966: Newburyport 49, Amesbury 0
1965: Newburyport 27, Amesbury 8
1964: Amesbury 14, Newburyport 0
1963: Amesbury 8, Newburyport 6
1962: Amesbury 6, Newburyport 0
1961: Newburyport 22, Amesbury 8
1960: Amesbury 32, Newburyport 16
1959: Newburyport 28, Amesbury 0
1958: Newburyport 20, Amesbury 16
1957: Amesbury 6, Newburyport 0
1956: Newburyport 13, Amesbury 0
1955: Newburyport 13, Amesbury 6
1954: Newburyport 7, Amesbury 6
1953: Newburyport 34, Amesbury 13
1952: Amesbury 15, Newburyport 12
1951: Amesbury 99, Newburyport 6
1950: Amesbury 47, Newburyport 20
1949: Amesbury 51, Newburyport 18
1948: Amesbury 25, Newburyport 13
1947: Amesbury 33, Newburyport 20
1946: Amesbury 33, Newburyport 18
1945: Amesbury 25, Newburyport 6
1944: Amesbury 40, Newburyport 6
1943: Amesbury 33, Newburyport 6
1942: Newburyport 6, Amesbury 0
1941: Newburyport 9, Amesbury 7
1940: Newburyport 3, Amesbury 0
1939: Tie, 7-7
1938: Amesbury 19, Newburyport 0
1937: Amesbury 25, Newburyport 0
1936: Newburyport 18, Amesbury 0
1935: Tie, 0-0
1934: Newburyport 26, Amesbury 0
1933: Amesbury 6, Newburyport 0
1932: Tie, 0-0
1931: Newburyport 20, Amesbury 6 (Not played on Thanksgiving Day)
1927-30: No Games
1926: Amesbury 27, Newburyport 0
1925: Tie, 0-0
1922-24: No Games
1921: Amesbury 14, Newburyport 7
1920: Tie, 0-0
1919: Newburyport 6, Amesbury 0
1918: No Game
1917: Tie, 6-6
1916: Amesbury 13, Newburyport 6
1915: Newburyport 25, Amesbury 0
*Games from 1891-1914 remain unsanctioned by both schools.
1909-14: No Games
1908: Newburyport, 6-0
1900-07: No Games
1899: Amesbury, 11-0
1898: Tie, 6-6
1897: Amesbury, 6-0
1896: Newburyport, 30-0
1895: No Game
1894: Tie, 0-0
1893: Tie, 0-0 (second game)
1893: Newburyport, 36-0 (first official game)
1892: No Game
1891: Newburyport, 11-10
For the J. Walter Chase Trophy
2023: Newburyport 44, Amesbury 26 (The 100th Game)
2022: Amesbury 38, Newburyport 14
2021: Amesbury 12, Newburyport 7
2020: Season moved due to Covid-19 - No Game
2019: Newburyport 34, Amesbury 20
2018: Amesbury 8, Newburyport 0
2017: Newburyport 27, Amesbury 0
2016: Amesbury 22, Newburyport 17
2015: Newburyport 36, Amesbury 34 (OT)
2014: Newburyport 27, Amesbury 20
2013: Newburyport 21, Amesbury 7
2012: Amesbury 13, Newburyport 10
2011: Newburyport 24, Amesbury 6
2010: Newburyport 26, Amesbury 0
2009: Newburyport 33, Amesbury 0
2008: Amesbury 22, Newburyport 7
2007: Amesbury 17, Newburyport 12
2006: Amesbury 20, Newburyport 0
2005: Newburyport 20, Amesbury 0
2004: Newburyport 24, Amesbury 14
2003: Amesbury 27, Newburyport 7
2002: Newburyport 28, Amesbury 6
2001: Newburyport 46, Amesbury 16
2000: Newburyport 26, Amesbury 24
1999: Newburyport 34, Amesbury 0
1998: Newburyport 35, Amesbury 19
1997: Newburyport 42, Amesbury 6
1996: Amesbury 38, Newburyport 8
1995: Newburyport 34, Amesbury 0
1994: Newburyport 19, Amesbury 7
1993: Amesbury 14, Newburyport 0
1992: Amesbury 23, Newburyport 6
1991: Amesbury 26, Newburyport 14
1990: Newburyport 42, Amesbury 14
1989: Amesbury 35, Newburyport 6
1988: Amesbury 39, Newburyport 20
1987: Newburyport 6, Amesbury 3
1986: Amesbury 14, Newburyport 0
1985: Newburyport 20, Amesbury 14 (OT)
1984: Newburyport 25, Amesbury 14
1983: Newburyport 48, Amesbury 8
1982: Amesbury 31, Newburyport 7
1981: Newburyport 18, Amesbury 7
1980: Newburyport 26, Amesbury 6
1979: Amesbury 12, Newburyport 7
1978: Newburyport 14, Amesbury 12
1977: Newburyport 41, Amesbury 8
1976: Newburyport 35, Amesbury 0
1975: Newburyport 31, Amesbury 8 – First year that the Chase Trophy was awarded
1974: Newburyport 21, Amesbury 13
1973: Newburyport 32, Amesbury 8
1972: Newburyport 30, Amesbury 6
1971: Amesbury 16, Newburyport 0
1970: Amesbury 28, Newburyport 20
1969: Newburyport 42, Amesbury 14
1968: Newburyport 42, Amesbury 26
1967: Newburyport 34, Amesbury 0
1966: Newburyport 49, Amesbury 0
1965: Newburyport 27, Amesbury 8
1964: Amesbury 14, Newburyport 0
1963: Amesbury 8, Newburyport 6
1962: Amesbury 6, Newburyport 0
1961: Newburyport 22, Amesbury 8
1960: Amesbury 32, Newburyport 16
1959: Newburyport 28, Amesbury 0
1958: Newburyport 20, Amesbury 16
1957: Amesbury 6, Newburyport 0
1956: Newburyport 13, Amesbury 0
1955: Newburyport 13, Amesbury 6
1954: Newburyport 7, Amesbury 6
1953: Newburyport 34, Amesbury 13
1952: Amesbury 15, Newburyport 12
1951: Amesbury 99, Newburyport 6
1950: Amesbury 47, Newburyport 20
1949: Amesbury 51, Newburyport 18
1948: Amesbury 25, Newburyport 13
1947: Amesbury 33, Newburyport 20
1946: Amesbury 33, Newburyport 18
1945: Amesbury 25, Newburyport 6
1944: Amesbury 40, Newburyport 6
1943: Amesbury 33, Newburyport 6
1942: Newburyport 6, Amesbury 0
1941: Newburyport 9, Amesbury 7
1940: Newburyport 3, Amesbury 0
1939: Tie, 7-7
1938: Amesbury 19, Newburyport 0
1937: Amesbury 25, Newburyport 0
1936: Newburyport 18, Amesbury 0
1935: Tie, 0-0
1934: Newburyport 26, Amesbury 0
1933: Amesbury 6, Newburyport 0
1932: Tie, 0-0
1931: Newburyport 20, Amesbury 6 (Not played on Thanksgiving Day)
1927-30: No Games
1926: Amesbury 27, Newburyport 0
1925: Tie, 0-0
1922-24: No Games
1921: Amesbury 14, Newburyport 7
1920: Tie, 0-0
1919: Newburyport 6, Amesbury 0
1918: No Game
1917: Tie, 6-6
1916: Amesbury 13, Newburyport 6
1915: Newburyport 25, Amesbury 0
*Games from 1891-1914 remain unsanctioned by both schools.
1909-14: No Games
1908: Newburyport, 6-0
1900-07: No Games
1899: Amesbury, 11-0
1898: Tie, 6-6
1897: Amesbury, 6-0
1896: Newburyport, 30-0
1895: No Game
1894: Tie, 0-0
1893: Tie, 0-0 (second game)
1893: Newburyport, 36-0 (first official game)
1892: No Game
1891: Newburyport, 11-10
The annual and often confusing history of the Newburyport - Amesbury Thanksgiving Game
In 1876, the United States began its centennial celebration while still climbing from the depths of the Civil War and Reconstruction; the first patient for the telephone was submitted by Alexander Graham Bell and at the Massasoit convention, the first rules for American football were written. Walter Camp, who would become known as the father of American football, first became involved with the game.
It took several years, however, American Football began to take root in collegiate halls and seep into the local towns of the eastern and northeastern United States. Many towns did not immediately adopt football as an interscholastic school sanctioned activity. So in many communities, the local YMCA or athletic clubs became some of the earliest documented local teams in the infancy of American Football.
Thanks to painstaking efforts by the late Bert Spofford (legendary local coach and sports writer), much of the history and mystery between Newburyport and Amesbury´s Thanksgiving rivalry was unraveled (Bert and Bill Peabody’s article below). Still, questions remain. As with many of the historic rivalry games, especially those extending back over 100 years, the early years of NHS vs. AHS are steeped in folklore and suspicion. Why are these early contests “unsanctioned by both schools”?
According to record, the two schools have officially competed in 99 official games in a little over a century, with some un-official meetings as far back as 1891. The early years were a scrum of athletic clubs (YMCA’s), local mill workers, high school students, non-league contests, rugby and then American football rules as the game evolved. Some early documented contests detail games featuring no officials, older men who were not students and some suspect conflicting reporting depending on which side of the bridge you lived on.
Due to the research and available record, both schools agree that sanctioned league contests began in 1915, although programs existed in various capacities in both towns. Regardless of rules or who attended or sanctioned the contest, the fact remains; Newburyport and Amesbury hold one of the oldest continuous rivalries in the United States today.
*Games from 1891-1914 remain unsanctioned by both schools.
1891: Newburyport, 11-10
1892: No Game
1893: Newburyport, 36-0
1893: Tie, 0-0 (second game that year)
1894: Tie, 0-0
1895: No Game
1896: Newburyport, 30-0
1897: Amesbury, 6-0
1898: Tie, 6-6
1899: Amesbury, 11-0
1900-07: No Games
1908: Newburyport, 6-0
1909-14: No Games
In 1876, the United States began its centennial celebration while still climbing from the depths of the Civil War and Reconstruction; the first patient for the telephone was submitted by Alexander Graham Bell and at the Massasoit convention, the first rules for American football were written. Walter Camp, who would become known as the father of American football, first became involved with the game.
It took several years, however, American Football began to take root in collegiate halls and seep into the local towns of the eastern and northeastern United States. Many towns did not immediately adopt football as an interscholastic school sanctioned activity. So in many communities, the local YMCA or athletic clubs became some of the earliest documented local teams in the infancy of American Football.
Thanks to painstaking efforts by the late Bert Spofford (legendary local coach and sports writer), much of the history and mystery between Newburyport and Amesbury´s Thanksgiving rivalry was unraveled (Bert and Bill Peabody’s article below). Still, questions remain. As with many of the historic rivalry games, especially those extending back over 100 years, the early years of NHS vs. AHS are steeped in folklore and suspicion. Why are these early contests “unsanctioned by both schools”?
According to record, the two schools have officially competed in 99 official games in a little over a century, with some un-official meetings as far back as 1891. The early years were a scrum of athletic clubs (YMCA’s), local mill workers, high school students, non-league contests, rugby and then American football rules as the game evolved. Some early documented contests detail games featuring no officials, older men who were not students and some suspect conflicting reporting depending on which side of the bridge you lived on.
Due to the research and available record, both schools agree that sanctioned league contests began in 1915, although programs existed in various capacities in both towns. Regardless of rules or who attended or sanctioned the contest, the fact remains; Newburyport and Amesbury hold one of the oldest continuous rivalries in the United States today.
*Games from 1891-1914 remain unsanctioned by both schools.
1891: Newburyport, 11-10
1892: No Game
1893: Newburyport, 36-0
1893: Tie, 0-0 (second game that year)
1894: Tie, 0-0
1895: No Game
1896: Newburyport, 30-0
1897: Amesbury, 6-0
1898: Tie, 6-6
1899: Amesbury, 11-0
1900-07: No Games
1908: Newburyport, 6-0
1909-14: No Games
- 1915: Newburyport 25, Amesbury 0
- 1916: Amesbury 13, Newburyport 6
- 1917: Tie, 6-6
- 1918: No Game
- 1919: Newburyport 6, Amesbury 0
- 1920: Tie, 0-0
- 1921: Amesbury 14, Newburyport 7
- 1922-24: No Games
- 1925: Tie, 0-0
- 1926: Amesbury 27, Newburyport 0
- 1927-30: No Games
- 1931: Newburyport 20, Amesbury 6 (Not played on Thanksgiving Day)
- 1932: Tie, 0-0
- 1933: Amesbury 6, Newburyport 0
- 1934: Newburyport 26, Amesbury 0
- 1935: Tie, 0-0
- 1936: Newburyport 18, Amesbury 0
- 1937: Amesbury 25, Newburyport 0
- 1938: Amesbury 19, Newburyport 0
- 1939: Tie, 7-7
- 1940: Newburyport 3, Amesbury 0
- 1941: Newburyport 9, Amesbury 7
- 1942: Newburyport 6, Amesbury 0
- 1943: Amesbury 33, Newburyport 6
- 1944: Amesbury 40, Newburyport 6
- 1945: Amesbury 25, Newburyport 6
- 1946: Amesbury 33, Newburyport 18
- 1947: Amesbury 33, Newburyport 20
- 1948: Amesbury 25, Newburyport 13
- 1949: Amesbury 51, Newburyport 18
- 1950: Amesbury 47, Newburyport 20
- 1951: Amesbury 99, Newburyport 6
- 1952: Amesbury 15, Newburyport 12
- 1953: Newburyport 34, Amesbury 13
- 1954: Newburyport 7, Amesbury 6
- 1955: Newburyport 13, Amesbury 6
- 1956: Newburyport 13, Amesbury 0
- 1957: Amesbury 6, Newburyport 0
- 1958: Newburyport 20, Amesbury 16
- 1959: Newburyport 28, Amesbury 0
- 1960: Amesbury 32, Newburyport 16
- 1961: Newburyport 22, Amesbury 8
- 1962: Amesbury 6, Newburyport 0
- 1963: Amesbury 8, Newburyport 6
- 1964: Amesbury 14, Newburyport 0
- 1965: Newburyport 27, Amesbury 8
- 1966: Newburyport 49, Amesbury 0
- 1967: Newburyport 34, Amesbury 0
- 1968: Newburyport 42, Amesbury 26
- 1969: Newburyport 42, Amesbury 14
- 1970: Amesbury 28, Newburyport 20
- 1971: Amesbury 16, Newburyport 0
- 1972: Newburyport 30, Amesbury 6
- 1973: Newburyport 32, Amesbury 8
- 1974: Newburyport 21, Amesbury 13
- 1975: Newburyport 31, Amesbury 8 – First year that the Chase Trophy was awarded
- 1976: Newburyport 35, Amesbury 0
- 1977: Newburyport 41, Amesbury 8
- 1978: Newburyport 14, Amesbury 12
- 1979: Amesbury 12, Newburyport 7
- 1980: Newburyport 26, Amesbury 6
- 1981: Newburyport 18, Amesbury 7
- 1982: Amesbury 31, Newburyport 7
- 1983: Newburyport 48, Amesbury 8
- 1984: Newburyport 25, Amesbury 14
- 1985: Newburyport 20, Amesbury 14 (OT)
- 1986: Amesbury 14, Newburyport 0
- 1987: Newburyport 6, Amesbury 3
- 1988: Amesbury 39, Newburyport 20
- 1989: Amesbury 35, Newburyport 6
- 1990: Newburyport 42, Amesbury 14
- 1991: Amesbury 26, Newburyport 14
- 1992: Amesbury 23, Newburyport 6
- 1993: Amesbury 14, Newburyport 0
- 1994: Newburyport 19, Amesbury 7
- 1995: Newburyport 34, Amesbury 0
- 1996: Amesbury 38, Newburyport 8
- 1997: Newburyport 42, Amesbury 6
- 1998: Newburyport 35, Amesbury 19
- 1999: Newburyport 34, Amesbury 0
- 2000: Newburyport 26, Amesbury 24
- 2001: Newburyport 46, Amesbury 16
- 2002: Newburyport 28, Amesbury 6
- 2003: Amesbury 27, Newburyport 7
- 2004: Newburyport 24, Amesbury 14
- 2005: Newburyport 20, Amesbury 0
- 2006: Amesbury 20, Newburyport 0
- 2007: Amesbury 17, Newburyport 12
- 2008: Amesbury 22, Newburyport 7
- 2009: Newburyport 33, Amesbury 0
- 2010: Newburyport 26, Amesbury 0
- 2011: Newburyport 24, Amesbury 6
- 2012: Amesbury 13, Newburyport 10
- 2013: Newburyport 21, Amesbury 7
- 2014: Newburyport 27, Amesbury 20
- 2015: Newburyport 36, Amesbury 34 (OT)
- 2016: Amesbury 22, Newburyport 17
- 2017: Newburyport 27, Amesbury 0
- 2018: Amesbury 8, Newburyport 0
- 2019: Newburyport 34, Amesbury 20
- 2020: Season moved due to Covid-19 - No Game
- 2020: Season moved due to Covid-19 - No Game
- 2021: Amesbury 12, Newburyport 7
- 2022: Amesbury 38, Newburyport 14
- 2023: Newburyport 44, Amesbury 26